It’s Memorial Day here in the U.S., a day when most people have off work due to the sacrifices made by our military, and thus spend much of the day incinerating and then consuming animal flesh.
It’s kind of an odd holiday when you think of it that way.
Anyway, I’m not really going to be around today, so I thought I’d open the floor for discussion. The topic is “memorials.” Tell us your favorite defunct band or deceased musician. What did they mean to you? What did they mean to music?
I’m not sure if they’re my all-time favorite, but I have to put Jawbox up near the top of the list. Even though they recently reunited to play a song on Jimmy Fallon, as far as I know the band has no plans to really get back together. And while singer J. Robbins’ later bands have shared a lot in common with Jawbox’s sound, they were never quite the same.
The thing about Jawbox is that they took this very serious post-punk, indie style (think Fugazi) and managed to make it astonishingly listenable. And as the band progressed and evolved, their music became more complex — almost symphonic near the end — while still maintaining that accessibility. There are moments on their last album, 1996′s Jawbox (Amazon), that are just staggering in their beauty and innovative songwriting. Moments where big, thick, weird chords match with drum beats that really should not work with the song but somehow absolutely do. Snippets of lyrics that are closer to poetry — I mean, real poetry — than you hear in at least 90 percent of other music.
This was by far my favorite album of theirs…so of course they broke up shortly after releasing it. I’ll never forget seeing that they had a show in Chicago while I was living there, but deciding not to go because I had friends in town, reasoning that I’d catch them the next time around. There was no next time.
(Now, to be fair, I also have a soft spot in my heart for the band members themselves, since my old band got the opportunity to open for them a few times, and they were some of the kindest people I’d ever met. Bassist Kim Coletta actually pulled rank on a local promoter because he wanted to knock us off one of their shows — this while I was still in college and our guitarist was still in high school. How nice is that?)
Anyway, the band is still virtually unknown, but so many indie and post-punk bands owe them a huge debt, whether they realize it or not. And I still hold a small hope deep in my heart that they’ll get together for just one more tour so I can make up for that missed opportunity.
You know what, I’ll put a playlist after the break so you can share in my adoration. Meanwhile, who do you love that’s now gone, but not forgotten? Share with us all in comments. And hey: Have a happy Memorial Day.
These songs are in reverse chronological order: One from each of their studio albums, plus one (“68″) from their B-side-and-rarities retrospective My Scrapbook of Fatal Accidents.

Favorite Deceased Musician? Oh my, where to begin? One can only imagine what the world would be like with them still alive (or lived longer), as well as the shape of todays music. To name a few…
Dimebag Darrell
Cliff Burton
Randy Rhoads
Stevie Ray Vaughan
John Lennon
George Harrison
Ronnie James Dio
Really, this list could go on forever, and spark many debates. These people meant a lot to me, for my musical tastes have been affected by them in one way or another. I feel lucky to have had them in my lives, and been able to see a few play in concert.
And thank you to the men and women who sacrificed themselves serving in the Military. A day off isnt enough to show how much we care (but its a start!)
I’ll go ahead and agree with Dimebag Darrell, Stevie Ray, John Lennon, and George Harrison.
For my list, I have:
Kurt Cobain
Nina Simone (born in my hometown of Tryon, North Carolina, and the people there are FINALLY beginning to appreciate this absolute legend)
Layne Staley of Alice In Chains (if you REALLY want a peek at how much this man could have changed music forever, just listen to Ring Them Bells by Heart from the Desire Walks On album, where he’s a guest vocalist)
Mary Travers (of Peter, Paul & Mary, one of the groups that had a huge influence on me as a kid, along with Heart and Genesis)
Elvis Presley
Michael Jackson
My list is varied and eclectic, much like my own musical tastes.
BJ
Seeing as I’m listening to AC/DC at the moment, I would be remiss not to mention Bon Scott. Aside from him, I can’t think of anyone at the moment who hasn’t been mentioned in the other two posts.
I was just gonna say, the recently-deceased Paul Gray of Slipknot, The Rev of Avenged Sevenfold, Hillel Slovak, of the early Red Hot Chili Peppers, Keith Moon of The Who, John Bonham of Led Zeppelin.